|
The presence of polybutylene pipe can severely affect a home’s
value on the real estate market. Poly pipe generally
takes 10-15 years to begin to show signs of severe
deterioration; therefore it is important to know what
problems can be caused by its presence, and what can be done
about it before it does pose a risk.
Problems With Polybutylene
Although some poly piping problems stem from improper
installation, most complaints are with the integrity of the
piping itself. Polybutylene pipe is known to deteriorate due
to contact with oxidants normally found in public water
supplies. The failure can occur in the plastic fittings or
in the pipe itself. A main concern regarding poly pipe is
that, since the oxidants are carried in the water, the pipe
deteriorates from the inside. This makes it very
difficult to determine if the pipe is truly in good
condition. Most home inspectors cannot give a reliable
assessment on the condition of poly piping unless there is a
visible problem with the exterior of the pipe or its
installation. In addition, when a leak occurs, it may be
extremely severe because the deterioration occurs from
within.
Poly pipe leaks are unpredictable and there are no
symptoms to warn of an impending leak. Some factors that
affect polybutylene piping adversely can include:
- Poor installation
- Water quality
- Pipe age
- Chlorine levels
- Deterioration of fittings (both metal and plastic)
When polybutylene pipe reacts with the oxidants in normal
tapwater, it becomes brittle, sometimes scaling or flaking.
This results in a fracturing of the interior surface of the
pipe, which allows for more deterioration. Eventually the
pipe will begin to leak, causing damage throughout a home.
Poly pipe with plastic fittings or with metal fittings will
eventually incur damage; poly piping is not a reliable
piping under any circumstances. If a pipe has been leaking
for some time without the knowledge of a homeowner, severe
structural damage to the home can result, making repairs
extremely difficult.
Damage from polybutylene pipe leaks can be expensive, in
some cases more than the original cost of the house.
Insurance companies sometimes cancel or refuse policies for
homes with known poly piping problems, and it is difficult
to market a home that has such an unreliable plumbing
system.
Identification
The most effective way of identifying polybutylene pipe
is to have your plumbing inspected by a licensed
professional. While inspectors generally cannot determine if
there is deterioration in poly piping, licensed plumbers
can confirm if you have poly piping installed in your
home. Typical characteristics of polubutylene piping
include:
- Blue, gray, or black color
- ½" to 1" diameter
Poly piping can be used anywhere in the home’s plumbing
system – usually its presence can be ascertained by checking
the attachments under household sinks, near hot water
heaters, or leading into toilets. Following is a list of
common places you may inspect for the presence of poly
piping:
Interior
Entering the water heater
Crossing basement ceilings
Feeding sinks, toilets, and bathtubs
Exterior
Entering the home through basement walls, etc
Attached to your home’s main water shutoff valve
Attached to your home’s water meter (often a copper
pipe at a water meter will be attached to poly pipe
somewhere underground, so it is wise to check both ends
of the pipe)
Note: Not all polybutylene piping systems use
polybutylene fittings; some use copper. Therefore, if you
see copper fittings on a pipe, it does not indicate
that you do not have poly piping.
Another important area where poly piping may have been
installed is the incoming water supply line to you house. If
this incoming pipe is a light blue plastic pipe, it is
likely that you have a type of poly pipe informally called
"Big Blue". This pipe is extremely prone to failure and
unexpected bursting. If you have this type of pipe as an
incoming water supply line, it is recommended that you have
it replaced as soon as possible.
Remediation/Replacement
The only way to eliminate the possibility of problems
that can come from deteriorating polybutylene piping is to
replace the pipe itself. Fortunately, this procedure is
relatively inexpensive and can usually be performed by a
certified plumber or re-pipe specialist. The process of
re-piping (both interior and exterior) can involve some of
the following procedures:
Exterior
Slight excavation with a trencher
Pipe-splitting (whereby the pipe is purposefully cut
in half and a new, stable pipe is run through it)
Deep trench excavation (in areas with an
exceptionally deep-buried pipe system)
Interior
The cutting of several holes in walls and floors
Poly piping runs behind the walls and under the floors of
a home, but while the re-piping of a house will require that
holes be cut in the walls and floors, a professional can
perform it with a minimum of damage to walls and other
structures. If there has already been damage to your home
from a poly pipe leak, then the cost of re-piping and
repairing your home will be increased considerably.
Property Values, Ownership, and Buyer Notification
When a home containing poly piping is placed on the
market, buyers will often discount the price (due to the
material defect) – even if the poly has not yet shown any
leaks – because it is known that poly piping will
leak eventually. If a seller is aware, it is wise to replace
any poly piping before putting a house on the market.
There are currently no laws specifically regarding the
disclosure of poly piping on a property, but some property
brokers have been sued for not disclosing the presence of
polybutylene piping in buildings they sell. Real Estate
brokers selling homes containing poly piping should be
prepared to be held liable if buyers have a non-disclosure
complaint. At the very least, both sellers buyers should be
provided with some sort of information regarding poly piping
and its dangers, and sellers should be given the opportunity
to replace their piping before putting their home on the
market.
There has been a $950 million
class action suit that may provide financial aid for
homeowners who have suffered damage from polybutylene piping
installed under certain conditions. The deadline is expected
to occur in 2007.
Polybutylene vs. PEX
Polybutylene pipe is typically gray or black, but is
sometimes blue. There is another type of piping – PEX piping
– that is more reliable than poly piping but is also known
to be colored blue. It should not be confused with poly
piping
|